Tuesday, August 26, 2008

A "Clear Vue" to Self-Referral



The self-referral mills in St. Louis were not alone in their approach to skirting the Stark Laws. According to ArkansasBusiness.com, there is another such operation in Lowell, Arkansas. In similar fashion, Fayetteville MRI, running a strip mall operation called Clearvue Medical Imaging, also depends on self-referral of its investors, and keeps it legal by avoiding Medicare and Medicaid patients.

Arkansas Business got hold of a confidential memo, which

. . . indicates that Fayetteville MRI – led by four northwest Arkansas doctors – is seeking 50 physicians to invest a total of $5,000. It anticipates annual profits that would quickly exceed $2 million from a controversial business plan that relies on self-referral.

State and federal laws forbid self-referral to imaging centers that accept Medicare and Medicaid patients, so Fayetteville MRI will not accept patients insured by those government programs, the memo said.


The article goes on to name the names of the owners and shareholders of the operation. They are actually leasing an outpatient clinic from a radiologist!
Their attorney is none too happy about being "outed":

Tim Ezell, an attorney with Friday Eldredge & Clark LLP of Little Rock and who is representing Fayetteville MRI, wasn't happy that Arkansas Business obtained a copy of the private offering memorandum. It was mailed to the newspaper by an anonymous tipster identified only as "A Concerned Doctor."

"It's really troubling to me that the contents of this offering memo are out there for public consumption because it really is supposed to be confidential," he said.


And he was very quick to point out that his little project is just within the limits of legality:

Ezell also said the business model isn't violating kickback laws.

"Those kickback laws are applicable to situations where there are ... government health care beneficiaries involved, like Medicare and Medicaid," he said. "There are no government beneficiaries involved in the Fayetteville MRI transaction."

Yup. When cornered, one of the physician-investors excused his actions:

Brown, one of the investors in Fayetteville MRI, said what's driving up the health care costs are attorneys who file malpractice claims against doctors.

"We have to cover our butt on everything," Brown said. "We know we could be sued and they always are looking in retrospect what tests I do that are not needed for my clinical care."

So if he orders tests, it's to protect himself from plaintiffs' attorneys in the event of a lawsuit, he said.

"It's all to cover myself from lawyers," Brown said. "It has nothing to do with padding my pocketbook."

Oh, puhleeeese. I'll go back to an argument I made earlier. All doctors face this same pressure. We know for certain that the self-referrers order from two to eight times the number of scans of those who don't own their own equipment. So, I guess that not only are the less-well-endowed committing malpractice, but they must be more immune to lawsuits as well. Wow.

Three of the four St. Louis shops closed after receiving negative publicity. We'll see if the light of truth has the same effect in Arkansas.

Thursday, August 21, 2008

If I Had A Scanner.....


With apologies to Peter, Paul, and Mary

If I had a scanner,
I’d scan her in the morning,
I’d scan her in the evening,
As long as I can.

I’d check her for tumors,
I’d check her for infection,
I’d scan her for the cash I’d get
From Medicare and Aetna
As long as I can.

If I had a PET/CT,
I’d scan her in the morning,
I’d scan her in the evening,
As long as I can.

I’d check her for tumors,
I’d check her for infection,
I’d scan her for the cash I’d get
From Medicare and Aetna
As long as I can.

If I had an MRI,
I’d scan her in the morning,
I’d scan her in the evening,
As long as I can.

I’d check her for tumors,
I’d check her for infection,
I’d scan her for the cash I’d get
From Medicare and Aetna,
As long as I can.

I don’t have a scanner,
I don’t have a PET/CT,
I don’t have an MRI, so much for my plan.

Cause the hammer of CMS
Rang the bell of warning,
And they cut off the cash I’d get
From Medicare and Aetna.
It’s all over, man.

Cause the hammer of CMS
Rang the bell of warning,
And they cut off the cash I’d get
From Medicare and Aetna.
It’s all over, man.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

Changin' Times

We haven't seen a total reversal of self-referral yet, but there have been some victories here and there. The Times, They Are a Changin'. Slowly but surely.

Remember the blatant self-referral clinics in St. Louis? There were four imaging centers that skirted the Stark Laws by not accepting federally-paid patients (Medicare, Medicaid, etc.) According to a follow-up article by Mary Jo Feldstein of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, three of the four have closed down. No one knows why this happened at this point, but maybe patients got wise to what was happening to them, or just maybe someone developed a conscience. More likely, they were about to get into trouble over insurance money:
Insurers are looking into whether the clinics violated a policy that requires physicians and facilities that care for some of their members to care for all of their members.
To care for "all of their members", the self-referrers would have had to take Medicare patients, too, which would disrupt their little operation. No doubt clinic #4, Cedar Plaza Imaging in south St. Louis County, is not long for this world, either.

CMS may have given us another early Christmas present. According to Diagnostic Imaging,


Following its charge to reduce costly imaging overutilization, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services has announced more stringent prohibitions against self-referral practices. Final Stark rules for the Hospital Inpatient Prospective Payment System for 2009 could force providers to restructure numerous space and equipment arrangements. . .

The new provisions broaden the definition of Designated Health Services (DHS) "entities" and prohibit under-arrangements and "per-click" arrangements for space and equipment leases. . .

The final IPPS rules will become effective Oct. 1, 2009. They will be published in the Aug. 19 issue of the Federal Register.
The implications for radiologists are positive. The new rules will take further incentive away from self-referral and will make lease arrangements with imaging centers less attractive, said attorney Thomas W. Greeson, a partner in the law firm of Reed Smith LLP in Falls Church, VA,

"It will also mean that many of the arrangements where hospitals have been able to establish relationships with referring physicians based on ownership or leasing of services on a per-click basis will be less attractive and give radiologists the opportunity to be part of the technical component services that otherwise were provided under these various arrangements," Greeson told Diagnostic Imaging.

This is a pretty big step. It doesn't cure the problem, but it's a start. Sadly, the self-referrers will no doubt find ways around any new rules and regulations that CMS can deliver, but at least it's getting harder and harder to do so.

Friday, July 25, 2008

GAO Talks, AMIC Squawks

The Government Accountability Office has just published a study with the lengthy title of "Rapid Spending Growth and Shift to Physician Offices Indicate Need for CMS to Consider Additional Management Practices." In brief, the GAO demonstrated what we already know, that in-office imaging is growing much faster than otherwise equivalent segments. Obviously, I'm not particularly surprised by this revelation. From Diagnostic Imaging's summary:
    • Medicare spending for in-office imaging services increased from $6.9 billion in 2000 to more than $14 billion in 2006.
    • The proportion of outpatient Medicare imaging performed in physician offices rose from 58% in 2000 to 64% in 2006.
    • Spending on advanced imaging, such as CT, MRI, and nuclear medicine, rose 17% per year, substantially faster than spending on less expensive ultrasound and x-ray procedures.
    • Cardiologists relied on medical imaging for 36% of their total Medical revenue in 2006, up from 23% in 2000.
      In-office imaging spending in 2006 varied nearly eightfold from state-to-state, from $62 in Vermont to $472 in Florida. The huge difference led GAO analysts to express concern about whether Medicare payment policies have emboldened physicians to overuse imaging.
The GAO did propose some solutions, primarily:

Given the pressures of a fiscally unsustainable Medicare program, CMS has undertaken several initiatives aimed at improving its performance as a purchaser of health care services. With respect to rapidly growing imaging services, the experience of the private plans in our study suggests that the benefits of front-end management of these services exceeded their costs. We believe CMS may be able to improve its prudent purchaser efforts by adopting strategies such as prior authorization and privileging.
Basically, they want precertification. This is a good start, but I really don't think it will do the job. Possibly there will be some minor effect in the beginning, but those who make a lot of money from self-referral will be more than happy to jump through the hoops to get to the pot of gold. But at least the problem is getting some lip-service from places that count.

The report includes a response from our friends at AMIC, who are none too pleased to have their masters' gravy-trains interrupted:


AMIC representatives raised four principal concerns about the draft report. First, they stated the draft report should have focused on strategies such as accreditation (which improves quality), and adherence to clinical practice guidelines (that result in appropriate use of imaging services), rather than private sector strategies such as use of RBMs, prior-authorization, and other techniques which focus solely on controlling
costs. Specifically, AMIC representatives expressed several concerns about RBMs. They stated that the for-profit structure and lack of transparency in sharing appropriateness guidelines make RBMs incompatible with the Medicare program. They also contended that there is no evidence that RBMs improve care or add value, and RBMs involve physicians in lengthy interactions. Moreover, they stated that prior authorization had been tried and proven unfeasible for Medicare for lack of sufficient administrative resources. In the draft report, we noted plans’ increasing use of accreditation to assure quality of imaging services. With regard to prior authorization and RBMs, we are recommending that CMS consider the feasibility of these and other front-end approaches. We would also note that while HHS indicated that prior authorization might be inconsistent with the Medicare program, the department did not rule it out as a strategy that had been tried and proven unfeasible for Medicare.

Second, AMIC representatives stated that in emphasizing spending growth we had failed to recognize the benefits of imaging and its effects in reducing overall health costs by substituting for more invasive procedures or treatments. We acknowledged the benefits of imaging throughout the draft report and noted that while some of this spending growth may be appropriate, financial incentives inherent in Medicare’s payment policies for potentially inappropriate use of imaging in physicians’ offices, and their implications for a fiscally unsustainable Medicare program cannot be ignored. We are not aware of any peer-reviewed studies that conclusively show the role of imaging in reducing overall health care costs.

Third, AMIC representatives stated that by focusing only on Part B spending under the physician fee schedule, the draft report did not acknowledge growth in imaging across other sites of care such as hospitals. As we stated in the draft report, Medicare’s physician payment policies contain financial incentives for physicians to directly benefit from higher fees paid for the provision of imaging services in their offices, while receiving lower fees for interpretation of in hospitals. However, we have added additional information to the report, noting that about two-thirds of all imaging services were delivered in the hospital setting in 2006, and that spending on imaging services delivered in physician offices grew twice as fast compared to spending on services delivered in the hospital setting.

AMIC’s fourth concern was that the draft report did not discuss the fairness of the payment reductions resulting from the changes mandated in the DRA. As noted in the draft report, we will examine the effects of payment changes mandated by the DRA in a separate report.

Blah, blah, blah. It's OK to talk about limiting self-referral, as long as we don't actually do anything about it, right? Well, the GAO is talking about it, and maybe CMS will eventually do something about it. I'm not all that keen on RBM's either, but it's a start, and we need to start somewhere.

The Today Show Mentions Self-Referral

A report featuring NBC Medical Reporter Dr. Nancy Snyderman was aired yesterday on the Today Show, which discussed mainly the amount of radiation one would receive from various tests. Self-referral was mentioned quite briefly in that patients were urged to ask their ordering doc if he or she has a financial interest in the scanning facililty. See the video HERE.

While the ACR has done much to bring imaging self-referral to light, they sometimes take too much credit. In a piece about the Today Show report, Dr. Thrall of the ACR said: "ACR media and public relations efforts regarding quality imaging and the effect of financial incentives on imaging quality and cost are clearly having an effect."ACR media and public relations efforts regarding quality imaging and the effect of financial incentives on imaging quality and cost are clearly having an effect." I'm sorry, but the only mention of the ACR in the piece concerns accreditation. Listen for yourself.

But, I guess any publicity on this topic is good publicity. Even if some wish to take credit where credit is not due.

Wednesday, July 16, 2008

Cheat Me In St. Louis

Just when I think imaging self-referral can't get worse, I find something like this. As reported in the Saint Louis Post-Dispatch, a lawyer named Kirk Bowman is managing four imaging mills in the St. Louis area. The business model is very simple:

Here's how Bowman's clinics work: After being evaluated by a board of directors, physicians who want to join make an investment that varies by location, Bowman said. He declined to provide details.

To remain investors, physicians must earn 75 "participation units" throughout the quarter. An MRI counts as three participation units. A CT scan counts as two. Then, the profits are split equally among the investors, he said. Physicians can miss the target for one quarter before being asked to relinquish their ownerships.

Bowman said the referral requirements ensured everyone's contributing to the center's being a success. . .

The referral requirements are so low, 25 to 50 patients a quarter, that physicians do not feel pressured to prescribe tests unnecessarily, Bowman and Schwarze said. And, profits earned are too small to tempt physicians to risk their livelihoods for a bump in income, they said.

You might think this little Ponzi scheme violates the Stark laws, and you would be correct, except for one minor detail:

The Stark law was named after its sponsor, U.S. Rep. Pete Stark, D-Calif., and was designed to protect patients and limit health care spending. It bars a physician from referring patients to a diagnostic center in which the doctor has a financial interest when the patient's care is paid for by the federal government through such programs as Medicare.

At least two dozen states have extended similar laws to cover all patients, but Missouri has not. Because the clinic Schwarze invested in declines to care for patients in federal programs, it is not covered by the Stark law.

Bowman isn't worried about the appearances:
"We assume people are honest. I don't know another way to do it," Bowman said. "I don't think a doctor is going to risk his whole career to manufacture an MRI."
Honest. Riiiiiiight. Just ask Dr. Jean Mitchell from Georgetown, who has written extensively about self-referral:

"There's no other business where you can control demand and supply," Mitchell said. "This is guaranteed success. It's a cash cow."

She sees Bowman's clinics as even more questionable because they require physicians to refer a certain number of patients to maintain their investment.

"I've never seen anything so blatant as this," said Mitchell, a health economist.

Neither have I.

If you happen to be in St. Louis, and your doctor sends you to Reliable Imaging of St. Louis in West County, Lynn Haven Imaging in Hazelwood, Cedar Plaza Imaging in South County or Boone's Crossing Imaging in the Chesterfield Valley for imaging, look him or her in the eye and ask how much he or she will be making from the referral. Then consider finding another doctor.

Monday, July 07, 2008

GE Is Worried About Radiation?

Fellow blogger Doctor Dalai has a recent post about SPECT/CT scanners. It seems that General Electric is trying to get him to buy a machine that doesn't do as good a job of scanning, in his opinion, but they are pushing it as the scanner with the lowest dose to the patient:
The following link is to an article regarding the possible link between multiple CTs and cancer risks, especially in children. Aiding us in our cause for our low-dose SPECT/CT Infinia Hawkeye 4 system. Maximum patient dose with the Infinia Hawkeye 4 is 2.5ma. Why more dose for Attenuation Correction and Anatomical Mapping in Nuclear Medicine environment?
I had to laugh when I read this. You might remember my post about GE promoting the sale of scanners to self-referrers from last year. GE has an entire web-page devoted to the joys of owning your own scanners, and how GE will help you get one. My favorite quote from their site is:
In-office CT also provides a highly credible and effective means of differentiating your practice from others in your market. It places you on the leading edge of patient care and may engender positive word-of-mouth that has the potential to increase your revenue opportunities significantly.
So, if you are "increasing your revenue opportunities significantly", you are scanning a lot of patients. Let's be real and admit that some significant proportion of those patients maybe didn't need to be scanned. Thus, GE is proposing irradiating patients for profit. That doesn't quite mesh with their great concern over the increased dose someone would get if scanned on another company's SPECT/CT. But I guess that doesn't matter, does it?

I just love it when people bend and use the facts to their own advantage.